Which Apple Pie Do You Prefer?

Both of these images were processed from the same raw image.

I played with a single raw image and created two distinct versions using different processing filters. I used the Kodak Portra 160 VC film filter from Nik Color EFX Pro for the first version. I used the DxO Film Pack 5's version of the same-titled Kodak Portra 160 VC filter to craft the second image.

After applying the individual filters, I gave both images an additional touch with an Adobe Lightroom ExposureFilm favourite film preset. This helped to add a cohesive element to both versions, tying them together through a unified filter that enhances the exposure subtly.

I'd like to know which version you prefer. Each has its unique flavour, thanks to the different paths I took during the processing phase. Do let me know your thoughts, I value your opinion in fine-tuning my photography skills.

Looking forward to hearing from you!

Nik Color EFX Pro Fuji Porta with ExposureFilm Favorite Film Preset
Nik Color EFX Pro Kodak Porta 160 VC with ExposureFilm Favorite Film Preset
DxO Kodak Porta 160 VC with ExposureFilm Favorite Film Preset
DxO Kodak Porta 160 VC with ExposureFilm Favorite Film Preset