Island in the Net

A personal website by Khürt Williams, with inchoate ramblings on technology, photography, and geekery.
Skip to content
  • Home
  • Blog
    • Photography
      • iPhone Project 365 Favourite Images
    • Tutorials
    • General
    • Experience Reports
      • Camera Review
      • Lens Review
      • Coffee Review
      • Brewery Review
      • Beer
        • Drinking
    • Letterboxd
    • Foursquare
  • Micro.blog
  • Now
  • Flickr Portfolio
  • About
    • Khürt Williams
      • Contact
    • The Ollivierre-McLaren Family Project
    • Mentions
    • Kit and Caboodle
    • Blogroll
    • Support
    • Legal & Blog Policy Stuff
      • Image and Copyright License
      • Privacy Notice
      • GDPR Compliance Notice
      • GDPR Data Request
  • RSS Feeds

7th August 2018 In General
Tags: Ben Werdmüller, Disinformation, Media, Misinformation, News, Propaganda, Social Media
by Khürt Williams
0 Comments
Read Bad news: there’s no solution to false information online by Ben WerdmüllerBen Werdmüller

It’s clearly impossible for the web as a platform to objectively report that a stated fact is true or false. This would require a central authority of truth – let’s call it MiniTrue for short. It may, however, be possible for our browsers and social platforms to show us the conversation around an article or component fact. Currently, links on the web are contextless: if I link to the Mozilla Information Trust Initiative, there’s no definitive way for browsers, search engines or social platforms to know whether I agree or disagree with what is said within (for the record, I’m very much in agreement – but a software application would need some non-deterministic fuzzy NLP AI magic to work that out from this text).

Imagine, instead, if I could highlight a stated fact I disagree with in an article, and annotate it by linking that exact segment from my website, from a post on a social network, from an annotations platform, or from a dedicated rating site like Tribeworthy. As a first step, it could be enough to link to the page as a whole. Browsers could then find backlinks to that segment or page and help me understand the conversation around it from everywhere on the web. There’s no censoring body, and decentralized technologies work well enough today that we wouldn’t need to trust any single company to host all of these backlinks. Each browser could then use its own algorithms to figure out which backlinks to display and how best to make sense of the information, making space for them to find a competitive advantage around providing context.

There is a lot to think about.

Like this:

Like Loading...
Post navigation
Prev
Next

Related Posts

UNESCO Journalism and Disinformation Handbook

9th January 2020  In General

Something for nothing?

17th July 2019  In General

Oily Rags

26th June 2019  In General

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Join 171 other subscribers.

Copyright © 2020 Khürt Williams
%d bloggers like this: